Hawkins County Commission considers national environmental law center for lawsuit

ExoticRidge is suing Hawkins County saying they are not receiving equal protection under the law violating the 14th amendment and Tennessee Constitution.

“The County Commission’s main priority is the health, safety an convenience of the citizens,” Commissioner Robbie Palmer said.

At Monday’s meeting, Palmer said he worked closely with attorney Crystal Jesse to find someone who can help fight the lawsuit.

That’s when they found Southern Environmental Law Center.

“Sometimes you want to swat a gnat with a hammer, well ladies and gentlemen we’re giving you a sledgehammer,” Jesse said.

SELC is a nonprofit public interest law firm. Director of Tennessee Office, George Nolan, addressed the commission saying they want to defend Hawkins County for free.

“Protecting our pristine environment is very, very important, it’s a worthy cause,” Nolan said.

The commission says they are concerned about potential health and environmental issues should a cryptocurrency mine be opened.

“There’s a lot we don’t know about the health effects of data centers and cryptocurrency mining, there’s plenty of information about the negative effects,” Palmer said.

The County Commission will review a pro bono contract and make a resolution about recruiting the company at their next regular meeting.

“It’s what the citizens want us to do, they don’t want us to go down without a fight, so to speak,” County Mayor Mark DeWitte said.

ExoticRidge is being represented by Beacon Center of Tennessee.

The company wants the ban to be ruled unlawful, the ability to run a cryptocurrency mine and compensatory damages, along with other items. You can read the full lawsuit here.

News 5 reached out to Beacon Center of Tennessee and haven’t received a response as of Monday evening.

SOURCE: https://wcyb.com/news/local/hawkins-county-commission-considers-national-environmental-law-center-for-lawsuit

Hawkins County receives offer of pro bono legal aid in crypto lawsuit

ROGERSVILLE — The Southern Environmental Law Center offered its pro bono services to Hawkins County, which faces a lawsuit against ExoticRidge Crypto Company.Lawyers from the nonprofit spoke at Monday’s commission meeting. Local attorney Crystal Jessee, who was called to speak by Commissioner Robbie Palmer, introduced the SELC lawyers.

Jessee and Palmer have criticized ExoticRidge’s plans to operate a cryptocurrency mine and data center in Bulls Gap, citing a community-wide concern for residents’ health, resources and way of life.ExoticRidge’s lawsuit follows the Hawkins County Board of Commissioners’ ban of crypto mines and data centers at a September 2025 meeting.

In the months since, ExoticRidge CEO Will Daugherty tried to assuage people’s fears and convince the county to lift its ban. However, at a February meeting, the commission refused to budge.On March 31, the nonprofit Beacon Center of Tennessee filed the lawsuit in federal court on behalf of ExoticRidge. The lawsuit argues that the ban unlawfully targets data centers/crypto mines. It also argues that the commission overstepped its authority and rushed procedures.

Jessee said she and Palmer reached out to SELC — first, about ExoticRidge’s air pollution permits from the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation, and then about the lawsuit. SELC offered to represent the county for free. Jessee said that while she previously offered to represent the county herself, SELC has more expertise on this subject.”As my daddy used to say, sometimes you want to swat a gnat with a hammer,” she said. “Well, ladies and gentlemen — we’re giving you a sledgehammer.”

George Nolan, the director of SELC’s Tennessee office in Nashville, addressed the commission.”[We do] what we can to help communities to protect the pristine landscapes and natural treasures that our state enjoys. One issue that’s a big concern for us is how fast things are changing in our rural communities,” Nolan said. “We’re seeing out-of-state interests come in and change things in a way that’s bad for nature and bad for the rural communities. This ExoticRidge bitcoin mining situation certainly got our attention.”Nolan said he and two other SELC lawyers, Joe DeGaetano and Trey Bussey, visited Bulls Gap today to investigate the issue, talking to people.

The commission had no questions for Nolan, except to reiterate that SELC gets its funding from donations, not client legal fees. Hawkins County Attorney Allen Coup also asked Nolan to share SELC’s standard pro bono agreement.

To receive SELC’s help, the commission must pass a resolution. Instead of suspending this meeting’s rules to introduce an out-of-order resolution, the commission chose to consider the issue in May. If this resolution passes, SELC’s board of trustees must also approve the partnership.ExoticRidge’s Daugherty was not present at Monday’s meeting.

SOURCE: https://timesnews.net/news/370766/hawkins-county-receives-offer-of-pro-bono-legal-aid-in-crypto-lawsuit/

“We’re giving you a sledgehammer.” – Crystal Jessee on help in fighting ExoticRidge

Hawkins County Commissioner Robbie Palmer said it best.

“They got their slugger, and now we have ours.”

When the Commissioners refused a settlement offer from ExoticRidge Crypto Company back in February, not even voting on an agreement that would have let the largely unwanted cryptocurrency mining operation locate in Bulls Gap, it was obvious that ExoticRidge would take the matter to court. Indeed, not only did they do so, but on March 31, got the Beacon Center of Tennessee, a non-profit but decidedly pro-business organization, to fight for them.

On Monday, Hawkins County received an offer from a legal heavy hiiter to take the fight to Beacon and ExoticRidge. The Southern Environmental Law Center, a Charlottesville, Va. based nonprofit with more than 110 attorneys on staff, visited Monday’s meeting and offered its services pro bono to defend the county against Beacon.

Rumors that the county would soon be securing representation had been going around for a while, but the official offer was made Monday after local attorney Crystal Jessee, who has led the fight against ExoticRidge since the company announced its plans last fall, addressed the board early in the meeting. She referred to ExoticRidge’s suit from the Beacon Center as a ‘hammer,’ then said “Ladies and gentlemen, we’re giving you a sledgehammer.”

With that, she introduced George Nolan, the Director of SELC’s Tennessee office; and senior attorneys Trey Bussey and Joe DeGaetano, who came from Nashville to attend the meeting.

Jessee credited Commissioners Palmer and Josh Gilliam with helping get the SELC involved in the case, and then Nolan, a native of Dixon County, took to the podium and spoke briefly about what the SELC does.

“We cover the entire state…doing what we can to help communities protect the pristine landscapes and natural treasures that our state enjoys,” he said. “One issue that’s a big concern for us is how fast things are changing in our rural communities, and the fact that we’re seeing out-of-state interest come in and change things in a way that’s bad for nature and bad for the rural communities that live there.

“This ExoticRidge Bitcoin mining situation certainly got our attention, and we’ve noticed the fact that the county is now being sued by an organization called the the Beacon Center that’s representing ExoticRidge.”

He told the board that they would have to approve the SELC representing the county, and then the SELC trustees would have to approve their involvement. He stated that if the SELC represented Hawkins County, it would be on a pro bono basis and would cost nothing to the county. One commissioner asked how the organization receives any money, and Nolan replied that they were a 501(c)3 nonprofit that is supported by donations.

There was no item on the agenda about SELC, and neither Mayor Mark DeWitte nor County Attorney Allen Coup seemed ready to vote on anything before receiving further information; Coup asked Nolan for a copy of the organization’s pro bono agreement and was told he would receive it. DeWitte said the board would vote on accepting the offer of representation next month.

Palmer, who represents the part of Hawkins County that ExoticRidge wants to locate in, was enthusiasic about the possibility of SELC representing the county.

“We believe the county government should have the final say in the health, safety, and convenience of its citizens,” he said. “We’re excited that this law firm is interested in talking to the county and working with the county.”

The Review will have more details on the meeting and other business transacted in a later story.

SOURCE: https://www.therogersvillereview.com/news/article_91b18914-9425-4804-a1b1-3c51214d3d07.html?utm_campaign=blox&utm_source=facebook&utm_medium=social

Crystal Jessee Of Greeneville, Two Candidates From Morristown File Petitions For Election To Unexpired Term Of Circuit Court Judge

With the qualifying deadline today at Noon for candidates wishing to fill the unexpired term of Judge William E. Phillips II , three potential candidates have submitted their petitions to be on the August 6th ballot.

Crystal Jessee of Greeneville, as well as Mark Stephen Stapleton and Aaron Joseph Chapman, both of Morristown, if approved, would be on the ballot for Circuit Court Judge, Part II – District 3, which represents Greene, Hamblen, Hawkins, and Hancock Counties.

Ad ends in 0

It was announced last month that Phillips, from Rogersville, was being elevated to the Tennessee Court of Appeals, Eastern Division.  He had been appointed by Governor Bill Lee to fill the Circuit Court seat after the retirement of Judge Tom Wright in 2021.  Phillips won election to an eight-year term in the office in 2022, defeating Crystal Jessee and Bradley Mercer.

SOURCE: https://wgrv.com/crystal-jessee-of-greeneville-two-candidates-from-morristown-file-petitions-for-election-to-unexpired-term-of-circuit-court-judge/

ExoticRidge resolution fails before Hawkins County Commission

ROGERSVILLE, Tenn. (WJHL) — Potential legal issues remain a center focus in Hawkins County after county commissioners did not vote on a settlement allowing crypto company ExoticRidge to begin construction and operate in Bulls Gap.

The resolution failed due to a lack of a second, meaning the settlement with ExoticRidge was rejected.

Hawkins County citizens clapped as no second was put forth, but this may mean legal trouble for the county.

Back in January, the crypto company put forth a settlement with Hawkins County, citing many “legal realities” that would allow the facility to establish itself, regardless of the initial ban put on crypto and data mining back in September.

“I understand why some commissioners and citizens thought a strong response was necessary,” Hawkins County Mayor Mark DeWitte said. “Strong action must also be lawful action. Decisions made outside of clear legal authority can expose taxpayers to expensive litigation and unintended consequences. Governing requires both responsiveness and restraint.”

DeWitte told the crowd that ExoticRidge met with the commission in an executive session in January, presenting its proposed settlement focused mainly on enforceable noise limitations. No votes were taken in that session, and DeWitte said he does not publicly endorse or oppose the company’s plans.

ExoticRidge CEO Will Daughtery addressed the commission and citizens, saying the company already had a substantial amount of documented commitments and permits before the September resolution was even passed.

He pointed out that Hawkins County failed to properly invoke the County Powers Act and cannot forbid a private company from establishing itself in the county.

“This commission had deemed Hawkins County a constitutional sanctuary,” Daughtery said. “Under Tennessee law, when a party incurs substantial obligations before a regulatory change, vested rights arise. Those rights are not discretionary. They are legal protections against retroactive government action. The resolution singled out one lawful land use and banned it outright without evidence of great impact, without water concerns, without air violations, and without attempting tailored regulation first.”

Regardless of possible litigation, many Hawkins County residents still do not want the facility in Bulls Gap.

Multiple public comments cited environmental and health concerns, as well as inadequate transparency from the commission or ExoticRidge.

“Mr. Will, when you were asked at the Bulls Gap City Hall meeting if you would be okay with your family or your children living near [the facility], you gave a very weak ‘no’ and moved on,” one resident said. “May I ask you what makes my family and my children any different?”

Some residents are glad the resolution failed; however, Hawkins County may find itself in possible legal trouble.

“Hawkins County comes to the problem too late with too little,” Commissioner Larry Clonce, who sponsored the resolution, said. “I understand your problems, but I don’t think we can win this fight.”

ExoticRidge sent a statement to News Channel 11 after the meeting:

We are disappointed in the Commission’s lack of action and resulting rejection of the settlement.

The agreement before the Commission addressed sound through enforceable limits and continuous monitoring across the entire operation. It provided a reasonable path forward while recognizing the substantial investments and binding commitments made before the ban was enacted.

Our legal rights under Tennessee law are not altered by tonight’s vote. We will consider our next steps carefully including almost certain litigation. Our preference remains a lawful, practical resolution grounded in facts.

ORIGINAL ARTICLE: https://www.wjhl.com/news/local/exoticridge-resolutions-fails-before-hawkins-county-commission/

Bulls Gap Dismisses longtime administrator Solomon

BULLS GAP — A controversial statement made by longtime Bulls Gap Town Administrator Mike Solomon — one in which he erroneously associated himself in his official capacity — cost him his job during Monday’s BMA meeting.

By a unanimous vote, the board chose to terminate Solomon’s contract immediately, and while he remained in the meeting to its conclusion, he placed his keys to the town facilities on the board’s desk before they adjourned, and gave Mayor Jim Riley some paperwork that he was no longer able to sign off on as soon as the meeting ended.

The board’s meeting-place in the Archie Campbell Museum was unusually full for the January meeting, as several concerned residents of the area attended to see what the board would choose to do in regards to Solomon, the town administrator since 2018.

The controversy involves the ongoing attempts by the ExoticRidge Crypto Company to set up operations just outside of Bulls Gap. Although the company has stated that it will use no public utilities and power its operations with generators using waste ethane from the NGL fractionalization plant next door, concerned citizens and elected officials in both Bulls Gap and Hawkins County cited similar situations in other areas where crypto operations and datacenters had a negative impact on the communities they were located in. The Hawkins County Commissioners passed a resolution in September barring such operations in the county.

ExoticRidge is contesting that decision. As part of the original application process, it had applied to the Tennessee Department of Environment and Conservation (TDEC) Air Pollution Control authorities for an air contaminant construction permit. It continued the process even after the County Commissioners’ decision, and a 30-day period for public comments opened on Sept. 23.

Solomon subsequently, on Dec. 1, asked TDEC Regional Director Jan Compton if he could “add my 2 cents, for all it is worth” relating to the application for the air contaminant construction permit for the generators proposed as part of the crypto mining operation. The permit was issued by TDEC on Jan. 7.

On Dec. 3, Solomon stated in a communication to the permit writer:

“I feel the permit should be issued, as based on current information, with Holston Electric’s generators, and Exoticridge’s (sic) generators operating on site, there will be no net emissions at this site. It seems to be that controlled combustion from an engine should be easier to adjust emissions, than it would be from the open combustion of the current flame. Electricity production, from the use of “cast off” fuel with no net increase of emissions, is a win-win for the efficient use of current and future supplies and resources.

Mike Solomon

City Adminstrator/CMFO

Town of Bulls Gap”

Although Solomon’s appears to be a minority position in the town and area, the main issue that the board and most of the citizens in attendance had was that Solomon signed the communication in his official capacity with the town, using the email address listed on MTAS, and not as a private citizen expressing a viewpoint. Solomon stated that he erred in not removing his professional credentials, but also said he had been asked for an opinion.

The communications between he and TDEC are a matter of public record and can be viewed on the agency’s online dataviewer, but did not become a point of controversy until local attorney Crystal Jessee posted them on social media on the evening of Jan. 11.

The fact that Solomon made the communication in an official capacity turned out to be the sticking point for the board. Solomon stated that he had done so in error and apologized for having done so, and also pointed out that his comments were not in support of ExoticRidge, but only that in his opinion, the proposed generators — a pair of 1,688kW engines that would run on the waste ethane — would have no negative environmental impact.

Riley said the communication itself “did not bother me a bit,” but that by associating himself in his capacity as town administrator, “in the eyes of the public, we support ExoticRidge. This is far from the truth.”

Alderwoman Leslie Tieke, who ended up being the second on a motion from Alderman Mike House to terminate Solomon’s contract, stated, as she has in the past, that she is 100 percent against crypto and data centers in the area and that such business brings nothing to the community, but reiterated what Riley had said earlier — that Solomon erred by signing with his title, and in so doing, created a perception that the Town of Bulls Gap supported ExoticRidge’s proposed crypto operation.

“I approciate Mike and everything he has done,” she said. “I accept his apology for his mistake, but it was a big one.”

Alderwoman Susan Williams stated “be careful what you put out and where you put it out.”

One person in the audience came to Solomon’s defense, while Jessee herself put in an appearance and distributed printouts of the full exchange between Solomon and the TDEC officials last month.

Eventually, Riley asked for a motion on whether or not to terminate Solomon’s contract, which had been signed on April 16, 2018 for a term of six years and then continued beyond April 2024 on an at-will basis. House made the motion, and for a moment it look like it might not get a second. However, Tieke seconded it after a pause of about 30 seconds, and then on a roll-call vote, all five members of the BMA voted for the motion.

By the terms of Solomon’s contract, four of the five had to vote to terminate.

He asked Riley if the termination was effective immediately, and when told that it was, he walked over to the board’s table and placed his keys there.

ORIGINAL ARTICLE: https://www.therogersvillereview.com/covid19/article_8e625e45-b16e-4a51-a3d3-5d5d07019bb7.html

Hawkins Commission bans crypto farms, datacenters

Residents of Bulls Gap came out in force Monday against a proposed crypto farm and asked the Hawkins County Commissioners to ban such operations in the county. The crowd was standing room only and many people had to wait in the hall outside the building.

STOP the Crypto Mine – Kingsport Times News

After the Kingsport Times News reported last week that ExoticRidge Crypto Company applied for a construction permit in Bulls Gap, many of the area’s residents decried the company’s plans for a cryptocurrency mining operation.

Attorney urges local utilities to sue over water contamination from PFAS chemicals

A Greeneville attorney is urging utilities in Northeast Tennessee to join a new lawsuit against manufacturers of potentially cancer-causing chemicals.